
Yesterday was not a good day on the anti-violence front. Those of you that know me personally, know that I work for an anti-sexual violence and anti-domestic violence agency. Yesterday I received an email from a disaster services response agency that we partner with that there was shooting, and approximately 20 were known dead, many of them children in an elementary school in Connecticut .. in just minutes following the event. Not long after that, the media picked it up, and it translated across the US, across the world. Also, across the globe, in China, 22 school children and one elderly woman were stabbed. Details were slow to come on the Sandy Hook tragedy, and rightfully so- authorities wanted to make sure that proper notifications occurred before certain details were released. That is only compassionate for the families of those killed and wounded. As of this writing, it appears that 20 children were murdered, and 6 adults. Two additional people found dead were the perpetrator’s mother and brother. The person wielding the gun was a 20 year old man. Twenty-nine dead total in this day of horror in Connecticut.
On the local front, the survivors that reside at our shelter were triggered, and needed our support. Staff prepared the moms to talk about this with their children in an age appropriate manner, and came up with a plan to limit children’s access to television, to the internet, etc… especially the young children. We prepared for the communities’ response as well, knowing that at a time such as this, sometimes folks decide it is time to flee a violent relationship. It would be much later that any of us would have time to follow the news reports closely or to log onto social networking sites.
In the minutes and hours following, and with details beginning to dribble out from authorities and the media, many took to social networking sites to express their horror, their sadness, and their sympathy for those experiencing this loss. I was interviewed by a local paper, and was damn near inarticulate due to sadness, and lack of information on the circumstances of the person committing this horror, but my comments focused on my heartfelt concern for those impacted, and that we could discuss the motivations behind this person’s decision to kill when we learned a bit more, but my concerns also lay with the larger community and the ripple effect that this would have on those who have experienced trauma in their lives, who may be survivors of interpersonal violence… and the impact on children.
To my consternation, many other things immediately began to be circulated. How easy it is to create an ignorant, mean, and self serving meme and pop it up on a social networking site. It is unfortunate that in life, things are not simple. Problems very rarely have a single root cause. We as human beings have what seems to be a primal need to determine a root cause, often to distance ourselves, or to lay blame. I would submit these actions are yet another way to dissociate in some way from the horror of it all. It is also unfortunate that mean, victim-blaming and items supporting a personal agenda lend themselves to short sound bites, comments and memes. It is disheartening that rather than using this time to support the victims of this perpetrator, and to use this event as a catalyst to start a meaningful dialogue about the issues we are facing in the United States… that our homes, our communities are not safe ones, folks started to proselytize for their ‘pet’ personal truth. There was an amazing glut of hatefulness from people who were consciously choosing to NOT see things from any other point of view but their own perspective, prejudices, filters, and experiences. Folks who were unable to realize that their view is not the only perspective. Things I heard expressed included:
- This is not a time to talk about gun control
- If you take guns away then the only people that will have them is criminals
- Comments that now the liberals have fodder to repeal the second amendment
- Comments blaming the NRA
- Mentally ill people should not have access to guns
- Anti Republican statements
- Anti President Obama statements
- Only people kill people, guns do not kill people …. [insert analogy here]
- Guns do not kill people, gun lobbyists do
- Guns don’t kill people, they make it easy to kill people
- Posts pointing out that the children in China survived, whereas the children in Connecticut did not have a chance
- Memes showing the those killed due to gun violence in developed nations
- Folks urging immediate anti-gun control violence legislation and action NOW, and the opposite… gun control legislation
- Memes and posts stating that since God is not in/not invited/not welcome in schools he turned his back on this event
- Posts pointing out that many perpetrators use religion as their rationalization for their actions
- Posts pointing to several of these attacks happened in places that were religious, such as the Amish school in Lancaster, and the other recent shooting in a religious school
- Posts asking ‘where was your god this morning in Newtown CT?”
- That mentally ill people are inherently dangerous/violent
The list grows exponentially with each passing hour. Ugliness seems to have little limit on the internet.
We know now that this young man had emotional issues and may have been mentally ill. We know that guns were readily accessible in his home, and arguably, a family culture. We know the fact he killed his mother, and Sandy Hook appears that the school was an employment site for her. We know that he also killed his brother. We know that after getting past security he murdered 20 children and 6 adults.
We also know that due to how this crime began, that it is consistent with domestic violence. Many think of domestic violence as a cycle of physical violence where someone in an intimate relationship is the abuser, not a brother, son, child. We know that interpersonal violence has an impact on children. The relationship is not directly causal, but it is statistically and strikingly correlational. Was their a pattern of power and control that the perpetrator experienced? We do not know that of yet- but if I were the betting sort, I would lay money on the fact there was. Does mental illness, domestic violence, etc., remove any onus of responsibility from the murderer? Absolutely not. When looking for reasons, folks to blame- the responsibility should be focused squarely on the shooter. No matter his demons or issues, he made a choice. He made many choices. He made a choice to put his hands on a gun, secure sufficient ammo, and drive his mother’s car across town. He made a choice to sneak past the recently increased security. He made the choice to kill person after person after person in a hail of gunfire. He then made the choice to end his own life.
BUT… There is always a ‘but’ in this life. We may be on different sides of the second amendment gun control/anti gun violence issue… but I can guarantee that no one wants innocent children to be killed. We may vastly disagree on social services and the responsibility of government to ensure that people that have mental health issues are able to easily access services without cost or resources being a barrier, that those who need intervention for violent behavior through services and/or judicial action and policing should be held accountable- but I can confidently say that no one wanted this to happen, save the perpetrator.
Again with the ‘but’- we are deluding ourselves and also doing the victims and our communities a disservice by not looking at the contributing factors, many of them societal/cultural. We live in a society where we are largely numb to violence and violence is incorporated into entertainment, games, music, etc. We live in a society where we continue to trumpet misinformation and myths. We live in a society where victim blaming is the norm, rather than holding those who make the choice to perpetrate accountable. We live in a society were guns are very easy to secure, legal or not. We live in a society where those most vulnerable are often the ones that pay the highest price. We live in a society where, instead of pulling together to focus on making our communities, our loved ones, our children, safer… we flame, name-call, bully, create hurtful and often MEAN memes that can be circulated worldwide in the click of a mouse or the tap of a finger. We live in a society where it is all to easy to close one’s eyes to the problem. And to those of you circulating the sentiments that somehow this happened because of our ‘godless’ society… I would ask you how that is NOT is victim blaming, and how that differs from the likes of Westboro Baptist who picket a solder’s funeral, or some of Pat Robinson’s many comments. We live in a polarized world. We have lost much through the acts of yesterday. We can use this in a way to promote healing, to compromise, and to work together to make a world where violence against ANYONE is unacceptable. Now is a time for real, meaningful and immediate social change through dialogue and thoughtful ACTION, and much remains to be fixed. Children are murdered. Interpersonal violence exists. Inequality exists. People can fall through the cracks because they are deemed ‘not worthy’ of assistance. This is not the time for vitriol, advancing political and personal agendas, and knee-jerk reactions that are of no impact to the problem.
What will YOU do today to make the world a better place? Let me give you a suggestion. Sitting on Facebook posting mean things, arguing and flaming is not being active. That is essentially doing nothing, and at worst, continuing the violence long after the last shot rang out. We can do better than this. We will do better than this. Our children are depending on it.
Will you join me?
I know we can’t all be self-absorbed dunderheads… Right? Right?
24 Jun 2012 Leave a Comment
by Terri L. Hamrick in Rants, Uncategorized Tags: behavior, children, Culture, movie theater, rudeness, self-centered, social commentary, society
Today I joined friends at a local movie theater. Sounds like a relaxing afternoon, yes? Actually, the answer would be a resounding NO. I arrived in plenty of time to park and to purchase my ticket at the box office. There was a line, but no big deal. It became obvious that after standing in line for nearly 5 minutes that no one was moving. In the interaction that was unfolding, I gathered the computer program that ran their registers was not able to accept credit/debit cards due to a soft freeze. At that point, a ‘gentleman’ in his 50′s started yelling and punched the plexiglass at face level of the stunned teenage girl working the booth. I was aghast! I said ‘Seriously?’ very loudly… And folks around me started to chatter… IN SUPPORT OF HIS BEHAVIOR!
At that point the Manager came out and advised everyone that the system was having issues and they would need to reboot it and that could take 4-10 minutes. She said they would delay that for a few minutes and before she could finish a young father yelled “Can you take cash or payment at the concession stand? My daughter here wants to see Brave and I intend her to see all of it!’. There was a lot of general grumbling, and I asked the girl behind the glass where the closest ATM was, and it was 10 feet inside the door. I waited in line, got my cash, waited in line again, and paid.
There was a lot more, but my point to all of this is simple- what message did the many children standing in line receive today? One of patience, compassion, and being part of the solution? No. They saw folks irate over something that was inconsequential and trivial, and saw abusive behavior supported.
I apologized to both the young people behind the plexiglass and to the Manager for the abuse they took today. They both looked like they were on the verge of tears. I did not do it, but I was not part of the solution. I hope to be more effective next time.